I have heard a lot of good things about the Etude House Proof 10 Auto Pencil eyeliners. Some deem them to be best drugstore pencil liners out in the market right now. So I checked them out in the store. My phone was out of battery and I did not have camera with me so I swatched the 4 shades available and came back home. I rubbed, scratched and even ran water on my hand, these eyeliners did not budge or smudge (oh rhyme!) I was quite impressed! So I bought the BR401 shade when I went to the store a few days late. I got the swatches on camera this time. I hope these help you decide which shade you would like to try next. I am yet to test these thoroughly on the eyes. It will the final test because I have oily lids and water-y eyes (I am so blessed! LOL)
BK801 Waterproof Black
BK802 Black Pearl Shine
BR401 Waterproof Brown
BR402 Ash Brown
PP501 Purple Navy (not in swatches)
I checked out 3 Etude House stores in the past two weeks and cannot find the PP501 shade (Sorry). But I found the rest of the shades and I was only underwhelmed by the BR402 shade because it was neither grey nor black. It looked like a dirty black (if that is even a color).
I like the rest of the 3 shades and I picked up BR401 because I already have too many black pencil liners – Avon, The Face Shop, Maybelline, L’Oreal – and I only have two eyes! I am glad that this auto pencil comes with a built in sharpener. I love using the pointed tips rather than blunt tips especially in pencil liners!
*Contains affiliate links
Have you tried the Etude House Proof 10 Auto pencil liners? Which color would you like to try?